**49ers Urged to Avoid Costly Mistake While Extending Brock Purdy After John Lynch’s Non-Guaranteed Claims**
March 2, 2025 – As the San Francisco 49ers prepare for a crucial offseason, the franchise faces mounting pressure regarding quarterback Brock Purdy’s contract extension. Following general manager John Lynch’s recent comments about the team’s approach, analysts and fans alike are warning the 49ers not to repeat the mistakes of other franchises that prematurely committed to unproven quarterbacks.
Lynch, while praising Purdy’s performance, stopped short of guaranteeing a long-term extension, stating, *“Brock has been fantastic for us, but we have to be smart with every decision. We want to build a sustainable winner, and that means considering all options.”*
Purdy, who led the 49ers to back-to-back NFC Championship appearances and a Super Bowl berth, has significantly outperformed his rookie contract. However, with only two full seasons as a starter, some critics argue that a massive long-term deal could be risky, pointing to past cases where franchises overcommitted to quarterbacks who later failed to maintain elite production.
Among the cautionary tales are teams like the Arizona Cardinals with Kyler Murray, the Denver Broncos with Russell Wilson, and the New York Giants with Daniel Jones—all of whom received lucrative extensions before their teams later regretted the deals. Experts caution that while Purdy has proven his value, the 49ers must structure any extension wisely, potentially with performance-based incentives or limited guarantees.
With other key players like Brandon Aiyuk and Deebo Samuel also seeking new deals, San Francisco must balance retaining its young star quarterback while maintaining roster flexibility. As contract talks heat up, the 49ers will need to make a calculated decision—one that ensures Purdy’s future without jeopardizing the team’s long-term success.
Leave a Reply